GUICtrlCreateMenuItem -- should the 2nd param be a default?

[Jaber <jaberwocky6669@…>]

The helpfile says this:

GUICtrlCreateMenuItem ( "text", menuID = -1 [, menuentry = -1 [, menuradioitem = 0]] )

It seems like menuID should be a default parameter.

[guinness]

Removed by revision [8970] in version: 3.3.9.21

[mlipok]

you talk about this:

GUICtrlCreateMenuItem ( "text" [, menuID = -1 [, menuentry = -1 [, menuradioitem = 0]]] )

If the answer is yes
then I wait too long -- it was on my list.

[Jpm]

Changing the doc is not enough. AutoIt code want really 2 parameters.

What is the menuID you expect to use by default?

I reopen the ticket as doc change is not enough

[TicketCleanup]

Automatic ticket cleanup.

[guinness]

It was a mistake from the previous commit 7893. The "default" parameter should have never been added.

[Jaber <jaberwocky6669@…>]

Yes Mlipok that is what I mean and I meant make it a default in both the au source and doc.

Jpm, I guess it should stay -1 but it should be such that it can be written like this:

GUICtrlCreateMenuItem("MyMenuItemText")

[Jaber <jaberwocky6669@…>]

But of course I now see the reason why it isn't a default parameter.

GuiCtrlCreateMenu("MyMenu")
GuiCtrlCreateMenuItem("MyMenuItem1")
GuiCtrlCreateMenuItem("MyMenuItem2") ; now -1 refers not to the menu but the 1st menu item.
GuiCtrlCreateMenuItem("MyMenuItem3") ; now -1 refers not to the menu but the 2nd menu item. 

Sorry for wasting time.

[Jpm]

no problem